Source Pacific Sun
by Jason Walsh
While the Marin Family Court awaits the results of a state-ordered audit of its family law processes, local court watchdog groups gathered outside the Marin County Civic Center today to protest the court's destruction of child-custody files in autumn of 2009.
The shredding of the files—which contained such things as images of children's injuries, illustrations drawn by children, witness statements, police reports and more—were allegedly ordered by court administrator Kim Turner about three months after state Legislators, including Marin Senator Marc Leno, called for an audit of the Marin and Sacramento family courts. Court detractors have for years accused the Marin Family Court of bias and negligence.
"We are unaware of any other instance where top state court leadership has openly admitted to destroying evidence in the middle of a state investigation and ongoing litigation," said family law attorney Robin Yeamans.
An investigation conducted by the Administrative Office of the Court was called for by presiding Judge Terrence Boren in July after a court transcript revealed that a family law mediator had destroyed files on the order of her supervisors. Boren has said the move to destroy the files was done to preserve storage space and that the AOC had prior knowledge of the decision. The AOC ruled that the shredded documents were not official court documents but, rather, notes and reports prepared by child-custody mediators and other advocates.
The protesters at the Civic Center are calling for a criminal investigation into the matter.
"This document destruction strikes at the very heart of our Constitutional system of checks and balances," attorney and Marin Family Court critic Barbara Kauffman said. "Top members of our California court system have endangered children and undermined the due process rights of parents who are now forced to defend against child custody recommendations that were made by historically problematic court employees whose files have now conveniently been destroyed."
To counter the charges levied by today's demonstrators, Marin County Superior Court officials were on hand to answer questions and hand out information packets about family mediation services. Among the info on the fact sheets was:
"Family mediator working files are NOT official court records. There are no California laws or other rules that require trial courts to retain family mediator working files. In fact, the law is silent on these records because they are not considered official court documents."
Are you receiving Express, our free daily e-mail edition? See a sample and sign-up for Express.
Posted by Louise L Mathews, a resident of the San Anselmo neighborhood, 10 hours ago
Does this mean the working mediation documents from the Flood Valley Flood Fee litigations and other civil cases which are handled in a mediator relationship can be destroyed?
Or is it just family court records that an be manipulated, edited, and destroyed?
What exactly warrants the term" official court record"?
ARTICLE SOURCE: "Family mediator working files are NOT official court records. There are no California laws or other rules that require trial courts to retain family mediator working files. In fact, the law is silent on these records because they are not considered official court documents."
Is destruction of family court documents "content-based"?
Posted by anony, a resident of the San Anselmo neighborhood, 7 hours ago
If anyone out there honestly believes the Court ordered the destruction of enormous amounts of documents a month after an audit was launched in order to SAVE SPACE, then I've got a bridge you might be interested in.
I mean a spade is a spade. Clearly they were covering up wrongdoing, and whoever this Kim Turner is she belongs in jail. Why would you destroy things like kids' drawings? The only reason is if some of the children are expressing fear or apprehension about a parent and the courts chose to give that parent custody.
If the Leg thinks the courts have made some bad decisions, they must have a massive paper trail of notes that probably proves that they put kids with bad parents. This is disgusting.
The County had better explain why Kim Turner continues to be employed.
Posted by jane, a resident of the Mill Valley neighborhood, 37 minutes ago
Thank you for covering this story. The destruction of important court papers has to stop and our courts must follow the laws to PROTECT innocent children. Family law courts need to protect innocent children and their families NOW. Are we living in a third world country?
Thank you for educating the people of Marin.